Why the US Dollar Is Falling Even as Stocks Drop

Why is the US dollar falling even as the S&P 500 dropped 1.1%? The DXY slid below 102 after Fed Chair Kevin Warsh refused to signal an October rate hike, breaking the usual safe-haven rule.
By John Zadeh -
US dollar banknote falling past a Bangkok skyscraper ticker showing DXY 101.783, illustrating why the US dollar is falling
  • The DXY fell below 102 on 16 October 2026 while the S&P 500 dropped 1.1%, showing the dollar's safe-haven role is conditional rather than automatic.
  • Fed Chair Kevin Warsh declined to signal what the Fed will do on 27-28 October, pushing CME FedWatch hold odds to about 72.3% and pushing the hike back, not cancelling it.
  • September payrolls of 29,000 against 90,000 expected started the slide on 2 October, and a hotter inflation print then swung October hike odds to about 50%.
  • ING calls the dollar overvalued with extended positioning, so small shifts in the Fed story can trigger sharp moves; analysts flag support near 101.80, 101.60, 101.34 and 101.03.
  • The cyclical drag from the Fed repricing could reverse within weeks, while State Street's structural case rests on tariffs, debt and fading confidence in US assets, and plays out over years.
Summarise with AI:

On Friday the S&P 500 dropped 1.1%, and the US dollar fell with it. That runs against one of the most trusted rules in markets: when stocks fall, nervous money usually rushes into dollars. This time the US Dollar Index (DXY), which measures the dollar against a basket of major currencies, slipped below 102 and kept sliding.

The trigger was a shrug from Federal Reserve Chair Kevin Warsh. Speaking in Bangkok on 16 October 2026, he declined to say what the Fed would do at its 27-28 October meeting. Markets had been leaning towards a rate hike, and that lean faded quickly.

Why the US dollar is falling matters well beyond currency traders. The same forces show up when you change money for a holiday, price imports for a business, rebalance a portfolio or decide whether gold still belongs in it.

Here is a working model for reading dollar moves, built on this week as the live example. You will come away knowing which questions to ask the next time a currency headline catches your eye.

Why did the dollar slip below 102 this week?

The slide did not start on Friday. It started on 2 October, when US employers reported adding only 29,000 jobs in September against the 90,000 economists expected, with earlier months revised lower.

Weak hiring weakened the case for an immediate rate hike. Then September inflation came in hotter than expected, and the odds of an October hike briefly jumped to about 50%, according to Axios. The market was being pulled in two directions at once.

Warsh was supposed to settle it. He did not.

“I don’t prejudge meetings. I don’t believe in saying now what I might do at the meetings we have in the balance of this year.” Kevin Warsh, Federal Reserve Chair, 16 October 2026

CME FedWatch, a tool that converts interest rate futures prices into meeting-by-meeting probabilities, showed about 72.3% odds of a hold and 27.7% odds of a hike on 16 October, per CNBC. A separate CNBC reading that morning put the hike chance at just 15%. The gap reflects how fast futures pricing moves within a single day.

Futures pricing can swing by tens of percentage points on a single speech, as happened in September when one Fed official’s remarks cut October hike odds from a 73% peak, so any single reading deserves caution.

October 2026 US Dollar Index (DXY) Timeline

Date Event DXY or hike-odds reading
2 October 2026 September payrolls: 29,000 jobs Hike odds around one in four (Reuters)
15 October 2026 Dollar peaks for the fortnight DXY near 103.00, closes 102.53
16 October 2026 Warsh speaks in Bangkok DXY below 102; hold odds 72.3%
19 October 2026 Monday trade DXY 101.783, down 1.35% over four weeks

Notice what did not happen. Markets still priced roughly 5 basis points (hundredths of a percentage point) of tightening for October and 25 basis points by December, according to Scotiabank. The hike was pushed back, not cancelled.

For you, that is the key lesson. A currency often moves on the change in expected policy rather than the policy itself, so a Fed that merely sounds less urgent can weaken the dollar without cutting anything.

How expectations turn into currency moves

Scotiabank pointed to narrowing rate gaps and a DXY sitting above its fair-value estimate. MUFG noted Warsh offered no hawkish steer. Put together, the chain looks like this:

  1. Fed expectations shift towards fewer or later hikes.
  2. Treasury yields on short and medium-term US bonds drift lower.
  3. Yield differentials, the gap between US and foreign yields, narrow, so holding dollars pays less.
  4. Positioning amplifies the move as traders who bet on hikes unwind those bets.
  5. Gold benefits, because lower expected rates cut the cost of holding an asset that pays no interest.

Step four explains the speed. ING described the dollar as overvalued with positions extended, which means a small change in the story can trigger a sharp slide.

How risk-on and risk-off sentiment moves currencies, gold and stocks

Rates are one engine. Mood is the other, and it helps to start with the simplest version.

Reading the regimes

Risk-on describes periods when investors feel confident and buy assets that can grow quickly but also fall hard. Risk-off describes periods when fear dominates and money moves towards assets seen as safe. Each asset tends to lean one way, for specific reasons.

Asset Risk-on tendency Risk-off tendency Why
USD Often weaker Usually stronger Reserve currency status and deep, liquid markets
JPY Weaker Stronger Japanese bonds mostly held at home; carry-trade unwinds
CHF Weaker Stronger Confidence in Swiss institutions and banking law
AUD/CAD/NZD Stronger Weaker Economies tied to commodity exports and global growth
Gold Often softer Stronger Gains when real yields and confidence fall
Equities Stronger Weaker Prices depend on growth and appetite for risk

The yen row needs one definition. A carry trade means borrowing in a low-interest currency, such as the yen, to invest in a higher-yielding one; when fear rises, traders repay those loans and buy yen back. Gold’s link to real yields (interest rates after inflation) follows the same logic: when real returns on bonds shrink, a metal that pays nothing looks less costly to hold.

The yen carry trade persists because a wide rate gap over US yields keeps borrowing in yen attractive, which is why the yen can weaken even after Bank of Japan tightening and why unwinds can ripple across global markets.

You can see the pattern working cleanly on 11 May 2025, when a US-China tariff truce flipped markets risk-on. The yen fell 2.1%, the franc 1.8%, gold 2.7%, and the dollar rose, according to Reuters.

What this week’s prices show

Here is how the major markets read over 16-19 October:

  • AUD/USD rose 0.6% to 0.6960 on 16 October
  • USD/JPY eased to 157.79 on 19 October from 158.02 on Friday, a mild yen gain (Saxo Bank)
  • Gold traded at $4,184.34/oz on 16 October, up 0.3% on the day
  • S&P 500 fell 1.1% on 16 October

That mix does not fit one regime. A firmer yen and supported gold look risk-off, a rising Aussie dollar looks risk-on, and the dollar fell regardless. When you see one asset move, check whether the others are moving in the pattern of a single regime, because a mismatch is information rather than noise.

Why the dollar did not act like a safe haven this time

On the table above, Friday’s stock drop should have lifted the dollar. The reason it did not comes down to one question: where did the fear start?

The October selloff was concentrated in technology, with the Nasdaq posting its worst week since late June on AI-related worries. The dollar got no clear haven bid. Instead, the yen firmed modestly and gold held up as hike bets faded.

There is a recent precedent. In April 2025, when US tariff announcements hit markets, the dollar fell alongside US stocks while the yen, franc and gold gained, Reuters reported.

The 2025 dollar slump According to Reuters, the DXY fell roughly 11% in the first half of 2025, its worst first half since 1973.

Episode Regime Dollar behaviour Main beneficiaries
Tariff announcement, 3 April 2025 Risk-off, US-policy driven Fell with US stocks Yen, franc, bonds, gold
Tariff escalation, 7-10 April 2025 Severe risk-off Fell against other havens Yen, franc, gold
US-China truce, 11 May 2025 Risk-on Rose Dollar, risk assets
AI/tech selloff, October 2026 Mixed risk-off No clear haven boost Yen (modestly), gold
Weak jobs repricing, October 2026 Risk-on for rate-sensitive assets Weakened Bonds, equities initially

The principle is straightforward. When a shock begins in US policy or confidence, investors may prefer the yen, franc and gold. When it is a global scramble for cash, the dollar’s depth can still make it the first refuge.

For you, “risk-off equals buy dollars” is a default, not a law. The first question in any selloff should be where the shock started.

Cyclical drag versus structural doubt

Two stories are running at different speeds. The fast one is cyclical: weak jobs data and a Fed repricing that could reverse within weeks.

The slow one is structural. State Street keeps a pessimistic multi-year view on the dollar, citing tariffs, high public debt, fiscal deficits, the current-account gap and fading confidence in US assets. That debate plays out over years, so do not mistake this week’s slide for proof of it.

Investors exploring the slower structural debate should read our deep-dive into de-dollarisation risk, which weighs reserve-share data against rising US debt and shifting central bank allocations.

Could the dollar rebound before or after the October 27-28 FOMC?

None of this makes the slide a one-way street. The same speed that pushed the dollar below 102 can pull it back.

ING’s view ING strategists Francesco Pesole, Frantisek Taborsky and Chris Turner judged the dollar overvalued against most G10 currencies, but argued a reversal would need a clear macro or market catalyst.

Hike odds have already swung from about 15% to about 50% in recent days, with hold odds now near 72.3%. One data print can redraw that picture within hours.

Rebound triggers

  • Hotter inflation: ING said upside surprises could lift October hike odds, though not necessarily above 50%
  • Firmer US activity data: Morningstar, citing Chris Turner, flagged EUR/USD possibly moving towards 1.11-1.12 if US data surprise strongly, which would mean a stronger dollar
  • Rising Treasury yields relative to foreign yields
  • Geopolitical stress that lifts demand for dollar liquidity
  • Stabilising equities that draw investors back into US assets

State Street, despite its gloomy long-term call, also allows for temporary rebounds given how fast the dollar has already moved.

What would extend the slide

  • A dovish tone from the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC), the Fed’s rate-setting body, on 27-28 October
  • Further weak jobs data
  • Deeper equity weakness driven by US-specific worries

On the charts, analysts flag support near 101.80, then 101.60, 101.34 and 101.03. Scotiabank sees limited support before roughly 101. MUFG adds a cross-currency caution: high global yields keep many Asian currencies under pressure, so a weaker dollar does not lift everything evenly.

The main error to avoid is treating a breach of 102 as a trend rather than a pause. A single inflation or payrolls release can reprice the odds before you have finished reading about it.

These statements are speculative and subject to change based on market developments. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

Reading the next dollar move with a clear framework

This week’s slide is mostly a repricing of October Fed odds, with a slower debate about confidence in US assets running underneath. The dollar’s safe-haven status is conditional, not gone.

When the next dollar headline lands, run three checks:

  1. What changed in rate expectations? Watch the odds, not just the decision.
  2. Is the shock global or US-originated? That decides who the haven is.
  3. Is positioning stretched? Crowded bets turn small shifts into sharp moves.

The 27-28 October FOMC is the next test, followed by the December meeting. Whatever the Fed decides, the language around the decision will likely move the dollar as much as the rate itself.

This article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Investors should conduct their own research and consult with financial professionals before making investment decisions.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the US Dollar Index (DXY)?

The US Dollar Index (DXY) measures the dollar against a basket of major currencies. It slipped below 102 on 16 October 2026 and was trading near 101.783 by 19 October, down 1.35% over four weeks.

Why is the US dollar falling when stocks are also falling?

The dollar is falling because the shock started in US policy expectations and tech, not in a global scramble for cash. Weak September jobs of 29,000 and Fed Chair Warsh's refusal to signal a hike cut the odds of tighter policy, so the dollar lost its usual haven bid.

What is a carry trade and why does it affect the yen?

A carry trade means borrowing in a low-interest currency such as the yen to invest in a higher-yielding one. When fear rises, traders repay those loans and buy yen back, which is why the yen tends to strengthen in risk-off periods.

What could make the US dollar rebound?

A hotter inflation print, firmer US activity data, rising Treasury yields, geopolitical stress or stabilising equities could all lift the dollar. ING judges the dollar overvalued but says a reversal needs a clear macro or market catalyst.

When is the next Fed meeting that could move the dollar?

The next Federal Open Market Committee meeting is on 27-28 October 2026, followed by the December meeting. CME FedWatch showed about 72.3% odds of a hold and 27.7% odds of a hike on 16 October.

John Zadeh
By John Zadeh
Founder & CEO
John Zadeh is an investor and media entrepreneur with over a decade in financial markets. As Founder and CEO of StockWire X and Discovery Alert, Australia's largest mining news site, he's built an independent financial publishing group serving investors across the globe.
Learn More

Breaking ASX Alerts Direct to Your Inbox

Join +20,000 subscribers receiving alerts.

Join thousands of investors who rely on StockWire X for timely, accurate market intelligence.

About the Publisher